Here’s some research about breathing and free will that ties in to Natural Dog Training.
https://medicalxpress.com/news/2020-02-mind-free.html
It’s about the experience of being in a body, with all the sensations that get processed and what that means to our awareness.
In NDT there is an emphasis on teaching a dog to bark. This helps the dog breathe and would therefore be encouraging the dog to feel more aware of voluntary action. I think the concept of free will in the dog’s world is intriguing. NDT is a very physical theory of behaviour, where actions are determined by laws of motion, much like gravity dictates the movements of planets and stars, rocks falling down a mountainside, and water flowing to the sea. In a determined system, with laws that give rise to actions, it must be incredibly difficult to feel free. I think there are two ways that free will can come to the fore. The first is to act against the law, fighting the determined pattern and swimming upstream into the flow. This is hard work and often exactly what we ask of our dogs – “don’t chase the rabbit, don’t bite the postman.” I also see this the opposite way around, where the dog refuses to engage with a toy held temptingly by the handler. The second is to accept the predestination, not through compulsion, where there is no choice but do the predetermined action “I have to do this”, but through desire, “I want to do this”. They are linked through the concept of choice and free will.

Leave a Reply