I don’t particularly agree with the central tenets of operant conditioning. Labelling the “four quadrants” reward, punishment, positive, negative seems completely arbitrary and at the extreme the labels are liable to switch to the opposite pole. With such inconclusiveness there seems little point in thinking in those terms without appreciating another controlling dynamic. As a quick example to illustrate this point consider being paid to work. One of the standard themes that dog behaviourists return to is that we give dogs treats in the same way that we expect paying for work. However, imagine being asked to work a little longer, perhaps on a Sunday or Friday night, and at some point the offer of an increase in pay will not persuade you. In fact the money then starts to become less attractive and can even cause resentment. The reason behaviourism has fallen into this trap is that the first studies used deprivation as a standard part of the technique. The problem doesn’t arise if you’re without. And conversely you can’t pay a well-paid company director to mow your lawn…
Adherence to these principles is then a cause of problems. Taking an inflexible approach, believing that operant conditioning principles are behavioural laws, and then applying judgement to how they can be used, leads to confusion and frustration. Nowhere is this more obvious than through negative punishment. The goal of the behaviourist is to affect behavioural changes through meting out reward and punishment. The environment controls behaviour so we arrange to withhold something from the operant’s environment to reduce a behaviour. This negative punishment is judged to be morally superior, a consequence that means the handler is still kind and “force free”, but leaves the dog frustrated. The seemingly benign act of taking away something seems to have a cumulative effect, like a dripping tap, constantly, repetitively, unrelentingly enforced. A chronic state of unremitting control that induces anger and annoyance with seemingly unpredictable outbursts exhibited as inexplicable behavioural problems.
This is not to say I’m advocating positive punishment. Indeed, I’m trying to throw out the entire bath not just the bath water. Training can and should include hard work. If anyone prepared themselves to run a marathon they might describe a punishing training schedule. In the same vein discipline does not necessarily mean imposed control, but can mean self control. My approach is to believe that, in whatever circumstance, the dog is just trying to do the best it can do. Perhaps too vague as a term for a behaviourist but to train and work with a dog it’s a useful starting point. I don’t want to reward and punish. I want to move past those and show a dog it can choose to resist either, become impervious to environmental conditioning and learn to be free. I don’t want to decide that some behaviours are good and others bad, essentially the whole palette of dogness is acceptable. I don’t want to control a dog but guide the development and create an environment in which the best the dog can do, can get even better.

Leave a Reply