Dog training for your baby

There’s a fascinating backlash against a Channel 4 programme child care program in which they’ve drafted in an expert dog trainer to provide behaviour advice for raising kids.

https://theconversation.com/dog-training-for-babies-only-if-you-want-to-raise-kids-who-are-anxious-and-unsympathetic-122150

For me the most interesting part of this argument is how it’s been seized upon as something that feels wrong to many people, in the same way that behaviour control in dystopian fiction, like Brave New World, feels wrong. My hope is that it perhaps awakens some doubt, creates a question for an enquiring dog trainer to feel uncomfortable applying the techniques to dogs too. Although on the surface there is obviously a lot to commend positive approaches the problem arises through a technical elaboration, a sophistication that removes sympathy for the other. The seductive idea of being able to control another when in reality we can do no such thing, even with our family pet. Of course there is control in training, but working with Natural Dog Training techniques doesn’t abuse that power and instead gives an increasing amount of control to the dog.

It would be great to see this develop into a larger debate. I’ve always been keen to discuss thoughts of dog training and behaviour. Unfortunately some people are not so open and the ranks of dog behaviourists do close down when threatened by alternative views. I would like to see the discussion widen the basic Skinnerian philosophy, perhaps including an understanding of intrinsic and extrinsic motivation and how it relates to dog training. The main complaint coming out of the above cited article is the reliance on technically advanced extrinsic strategies that can affect more than the overt behaviour. I think this is a huge unrecognised problem in modern dog training, apparently benign but developing stressful reactions in our pet dogs. Being inculcated with the understanding that their environment controls them leaves a dog with the resultant feeling of being out-of-control. My view is that the blend of internal and external motivations should be so aligned that the big things, the important stuff, is focused internally rather than externally. It’s also relevant to consider how inside-out the experience of a dog can be, where they don’t necessarily view internal/external sensations as we would imagine, the boundaries are blurred in a state of union with the world.


Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *